Skip to main content

Discussion on Lean Canvas and product market fit for 'Merishop'

Here, in this section we analyze the Lean Canvas of the pivoted venture, Merishop (the backstory of Meesho), and discusses its problem-solution fit and product-market fit.

Discussion on Lean Canvas for Merishop (Post-Pivot)

The company, Fashnear, made a significant pivot and is now operating as Merishop. The primary customer segment has shifted, and the product offering has changed.

1. Customer Segment:

  • Primary Customer: Local apparel retailers. Merishop now exclusively focuses on providing solutions to these retailers.
  • End Users: While end consumers are important as they ultimately buy products from the retailers, Merishop itself does not directly interact with them. This is a crucial distinction.
  • Lean Canvas Best Practice: When dealing with a distinct primary customer segment, the Lean Canvas should clearly reflect this singular focus.

2. Problems:

  • For Local Apparel Retailers: Merishop aims to solve problems like unsold products and inventory management.
  • For End Consumers (as identified by students, but not Merishop's direct focus): Problems include spam via WhatsApp and products becoming unavailable quickly.
  • Merishop's Actual Focus: The problem being solved by Merishop's pivoted strategy is for the retailers – enabling them to better manage their operations, particularly inventory and catalog.

3. Solution:

  • Merishop's solution is a software tool for small retailers to manage their shop operations. It's essentially an Indian version of Shopify.
  • The software enables inventory management, catalog management, and provides an online presence, allowing retailers to operate more efficiently and effectively. This is the core of their pivot.

4. Unique Value Proposition (UVP):

  • The value proposition for retailers is: "We'll manage your operations while you can go ahead and expand your business." This offers efficiency and growth potential to the retailers.
  • It's important to remember that Merishop's UVP is not directly for the end consumer at this stage, as their interaction is with the retailers.

5. Unfair Advantage:

  • This section can be challenging to fill at the beginning. Unless there's a patent or clear intellectual property, it's acceptable to leave it blank initially. "Leveraging local networks" or "innovative mall experience at home" (from the Fashnear days) might be easily replicable and not true unfair advantages.

6. Channels:

  • Channels are driven by the specific customer segment. For retailers, the primary channel would likely be an on-ground salesforce that visits shops to onboard them onto the app. The mobile application itself is the channel for the retailers to use the service.

7. Key Metrics:

  • The Lean Canvas is a snapshot in time, so metrics should be relevant to the current stage.
  • Early-stage metrics for Merishop would include:
    • Number of retailers onboarded.
    • Number of app downloads (by retailers).
    • Not necessarily long-term metrics like profitability or margins.

8. Revenue Streams & Cost Structure:

  • Initial revenue streams could include commissions, advertisements, or subscriptions, but these are potential and would evolve.
  • Costs would involve R&D, manufacturing (if applicable), marketing, app development, and customer support.

Problem-Solution Fit for Merishop

  • Assessment: Merishop does seem to have achieved problem-solution fit.
  • Reasoning: The case mentions 25,000 downloads of their software, indicating strong initial traction and that a substantial number of retailers acknowledge the problem Merishop is solving (managing their shop operations, inventory, online presence) and find the solution valuable. Problem-solution fit is about solving a substantial problem for a critical mass of people, which the download numbers suggest.

Product-Market Fit for Merishop

Product-Market Fit (PMF) requires two things: demonstrated demand and profit potential.

  • Demonstrated Demand: Yes, 25,000 downloads indicate demonstrated demand for the software among retailers.
  • Profit Potential: This is where the doubt arises.
    • The software is currently free. If Merishop starts charging (e.g., ₹1000/month), there's concern about customer willingness to pay.
    • Low Retention Rate: The case mentions a retention rate of less than 30%, which is concerning.
      • Retention Rate's Importance: A low retention rate means a high "churn rate" (users abandoning the product). This signifies that customers are not finding continuous value in the product. They might have downloaded it assuming benefits but didn't find them, or the product might be difficult to use or buggy. High retention is a key indicator of value.
      • Value Metrics vs. Vanity Metrics: Downloads or website visits can be "vanity metrics" if they don't lead to deeper engagement. "Value metrics" (like retention, activation, referrals) indicate that customers are genuinely finding value and continuing to use the product. A company with high customer acquisition but low retention cannot be sustainable in the long run.
  • Conclusion for Merishop's PMF: While there's demonstrated demand, the low retention rate makes the profit potential uncertain. If customers are not consistently using the product (as indicated by low retention), their willingness to pay for it will likely be low. Therefore, Merishop does not yet have full product-market fit.

Options for Merishop

Given the current situation (demonstrated demand but uncertain profit potential due to low retention), Merishop faces a critical decision:

  1. Continue Improvisations: Keep improving the app, engaging with retailers to understand how to add more value, and try to increase retention.
  2. Another Pivot: Explore a new direction entirely, as suggested by one student.
  3. Monetization Experiment: Start charging a small fee as an experiment to directly test customer willingness to pay and observe its impact on retention.

This situation highlights the ongoing challenge for entrepreneurs to constantly validate their assumptions and adapt their strategies to achieve sustainable growth.

Back to top