Skip to main content

Introduction to the case method

In this section we will introduce the concept of decision-making, particularly in entrepreneurial contexts, and explains the utility of the case method as a pedagogical tool.

Decision Making

  • Definition: Decision-making is a cognitive process aimed at addressing an organizational problem or situation by choosing among various alternatives. Decision-makers (managers or entrepreneurs) base their choices on available information, knowledge, experience, and personal belief systems.
  • Importance: Decision-making is at the heart of all action and progress. It provides agency, allowing movement from one point to another.
  • Challenges in Entrepreneurial Decision-Making:
    • Variety and Uncertainty: Entrepreneurial decisions inherently involve more variety and greater uncertainty than typical management decisions.
    • Imperfect Knowledge: Entrepreneurs often make decisions based on incomplete or imperfect knowledge. They operate with hypotheses about cause and effect, rather than certainties.
    • Risk of Failure: Due to uncertainty, entrepreneurial decisions are highly susceptible to failure.
  • Data for Decision Making:
    • Types of Data: Data can be subjective (e.g., nuanced customer views) or objective (e.g., market size, customer numbers, financial projections). It can also be quantitative (numerical) or qualitative (descriptive, nuanced).
    • Utilizing Data: Effective decision-making requires gathering all available data. However, it's crucial to distinguish "signal" (relevant data) from "noise" (irrelevant information).
    • Triangulation: Looking at a problem from multiple angles or using different data points to increase confidence in a decision.
    • Intuition: While not always articulated, intuition, based on observation and experience, also plays a significant role in decision-making.
  • Skill Development: Good managerial decision-making is a skill that develops over time through accumulating, classifying, analyzing, and building upon diverse situations and their outcomes. In entrepreneurial contexts, where there's often no past precedence, this skill becomes even more vital but also more challenging to develop. Purposeful practice improves judgment over time.

The Case Method

  • Purpose: The case method is a pedagogical tool designed to allow students to practice decision-making in a safe and secure environment.
  • Simulation: Cases simulate real-life situations, presenting problems or issues that require analysis and decision-making. Students learn to identify relevant data, analyze scenarios, consider counterfactuals, and arrive at a course of action.
  • Relevance: It is an extremely important and relevant tool because it provides a simulated experience for decision-making before individuals face real-world, high-stakes situations.
  • Broad Application: Originating in fields like law and medicine, the case method is widely used and highly popular in business school curricula today.
  • Analogy: The classroom, when using the case method, transforms into a practical environment similar to a hospital where interns practice diagnosis and procedures before working on live cases.
Back to top