Skip to main content

Rights of Surety

A surety is a person who guarantees the performance of a contract or repayment of a debt by the principal debtor. The Indian Contract Act, 1872, provides various rights to the surety to ensure fair treatment and protect their interests. These rights can be classified as follows:

1. Rights Against the Principal Debtor

These rights allow the surety to recover any loss incurred due to fulfilling the debtor’s obligations.

(a) Right of Subrogation (Section 140)

  • After the surety pays the debt or performs the obligation, they step into the shoes of the creditor.
  • The surety acquires all rights of the creditor to recover the amount paid from the principal debtor.
  • Example: If a surety pays a loan on behalf of the debtor, they can recover the same amount from the debtor.

(b) Right of Indemnity (Section 145)

  • The surety is entitled to be indemnified by the principal debtor for any payments made or losses incurred under the guarantee.
  • This right exists regardless of whether indemnity is explicitly mentioned in the contract.
  • Example: If a surety pays ₹1 lakh for a loan guaranteed, they can claim the amount back from the debtor.

2. Rights Against the Creditor

These rights help the surety protect themselves from unfair or excessive demands by the creditor.

(a) Right to Security

  • The surety has the right to benefit from any security held by the creditor against the principal debtor.
  • If the creditor has collateral or assets to cover the debt, the surety can use them to recover their payment.
  • Example: If the creditor holds a property as collateral, the surety can claim it to recover losses.

(b) Right to Demand Creditor to Pursue Principal Debtor First

  • The surety can request the creditor to exhaust all remedies against the principal debtor before enforcing the surety's liability.
  • Note: This right may not be enforceable if there is a specific agreement stating otherwise.

(c) Right to Limit Liability

  • If the terms of the guarantee are altered without the consent of the surety, the surety is discharged from liability to the extent of the alteration.
  • Example: If the creditor increases the loan amount without the surety’s knowledge, the surety may not be liable for the increased amount.

3. Rights Against Co-Sureties (Section 146 & 147)

When multiple sureties are involved, they share liability proportionally.

(a) Right to Contribution

  • If a co-surety pays more than their share of the guaranteed amount, they can claim contribution from the other co-sureties.
  • Example: If there are three co-sureties liable for ₹3 lakhs and one pays ₹2 lakhs, they can recover ₹1 lakh from the other two.

(b) Right to Equal Burden

  • Co-sureties are equally liable unless an agreement specifies otherwise. The surety can ensure the burden is distributed fairly.

4. Right to Discharge from Liability

A surety can be discharged from liability under the following circumstances:

  • Performance of the Contract: When the principal debtor fulfills their obligation.
  • Release of the Principal Debtor by the Creditor: If the creditor releases the debtor, the surety is discharged.
  • Alteration of Contract Terms (Section 133): Any material change in the terms of the contract without the surety’s consent discharges the surety.
  • Creditor’s Acts or Omissions (Section 139): If the creditor acts in a way that impairs the surety's remedy or security, the surety is discharged.

Summary of Surety's Rights

Category Right Description
Against Principal Debtor Right of Subrogation Surety steps into the creditor’s shoes to recover from the debtor.
Right of Indemnity Surety is entitled to reimbursement for payments made.
Against Creditor Right to Security Surety can claim any collateral held by the creditor.
Right to Limit Liability Alterations in the contract discharge the surety's liability.
Against Co-Sureties Right of Contribution Surety can recover from other co-sureties proportionally.
Right to Equal Burden Liability is shared equally unless agreed otherwise.

Conclusion:
The rights of a surety ensure they are not unfairly burdened and provide mechanisms to recover payments or discharge liability. These rights encourage fairness in contractual arrangements involving guarantees.

No Comments
Back to top